On the Problem of Truth
One of Jesus’ apostles once said something to the effect of, “Without love, your Christian witness is meaningless. It is an abomination.” In the Western world, be we Jew, Christian, or Muslim, we have lost the path of Love and ventured too far down the road seeking Truth.
In the West, the primary concern of the Church is not how to solve the problem of Suffering inherent in all men, but, Truth. In the East, suffering is very much an accepted part of life and the focus is placed on Love. For example, if you go to India and share with a Hindu follower a “truth,” he’ll most likely accept what you say with a casual shrug and a nod. In the West, if you go to someone and do the same, you’ll most likely start a nasty argument. The social rule about never talking politics or religion in a bar comes to mind.
In most denominations of Christianity, in particular, Truth leads to personal holiness. A strong “We’re right and you’re wrong,” followed up with an unholy condemnation is common. One quick looks at the attitudes of one denomination towards another, Protestantism versus Catholicism, in general, or the more relevant problem of Protestant Christianity versus the Islamic world as a whole shed more than enough light on the subject.
These “truth claims” have caused endless problems throughout history. You have the Jewish subjugation of the peoples of Palestine in the Torah, the Christian Crusades, the beheadings that were rampant throughout Post-reformation Europe, the Spanish Inquisition, the Islamic Jihads versus America and Europe or the Hindu peoples leading to bloody conflict, death, and suffering throughout the Western World.
In the West, we get so caught up in the intellectualism of our faith and the pride involved therein, that we forget Jesus’ message. Our contemporaries in the East, from which a lot of his lessons seem to be inspired, don’t have such a problem. My World Religions professor, Dr. Alexander joked in class one evening, “Burn a (Bhagavad) Gita and big deal, you have a barbecue. Burn a Koran and you have a war.” This joke seems like current event satire on the surface (see current issue of “Koran Burning and Ground Zero Islamic Center”), but, speaks of a bigger issue plaguing our theology.
In the 2000 years since Jesus’ ministry shook the very foundations of the most powerful Empire in the world, reformed a faith set down by God’s Chosen People, and altered the course of the world for 1000s of years… we forgot one simple truth, in itself…
Love is more important than Truth. Love IS Truth.
Jesus sought to balance the two. He asks of us to love our enemies. Bless those that harm us. Do not judge them.
We’re called to hold hands with the Muslims and the Jews, our conquerors and oppressors, our homeless and destitute, our widows, orphans, and those aliens in our lands, for they are our brothers under the same God. We’re called not to hate those that do not believe, those that do, but, think differently, and everything in between. Jesus calls us to lead by example and that example is Love.
Allow me to illustrate my point with something from current events.
Murfreesboro, Tennessee, population 100,000 – 30 miles south of Nashville, a large Baptist Christian center in America, a “gateway city” for refugee’s from the Persian Gulf War, a place with a booming Muslim population and anti-Muslim sentiment alike. Here, of all places, an ecumenical fairy tale is being realized. The Grace Baptist Church is helping the Murfreesboro Islamic Center by assisting them in building their new mosque on the property adjacent to their new facilities. Not only this, but, they’re currently sharing their space with the Islamic congregation.
The Center’s new construction has received harsh treatment from local Tea Party activists and many others caught up in renewed anti-Islamic sentiment stirred up by the anniversary of 9/11 and the publicity stunt of Gainesville, FL Pastor Rev. Jones’ threat to burn Korans in response to the mosque building near Ground Zero. Various other mosque building attempts have been blocked in nearby towns across Nashville’s suburbs. To go one further, Tenn. Lt. Gov. Rob Ramsey is quoted making this ridiculous statement, “You could even argue whether being Muslim is actually a religion or is it a nationality, a way of life or cult? Whatever you call it…” and Republican Congressional Candidate Lou Ann Zelcnik said the Center “is part of a movement designed to fracture the moral and political foundations of middle Tennessee.” Needless to say, both lost their bids. It’s a wonder such things are in the state they are with such ignorance fueling our politics, but, I digress.
To this writer, the Christians at Grace Baptist Church have the message right. They act out of love to their neighbor Muslims, respecting them as people and loving them as children of God despite their beliefs, the actions of other extremist Muslims, or the actions and bias of fellow Christians.
We are after all, only human… though, I feel that if Jesus could see us now, he’d look at the world, hold out his hands and with a shake of the head and deep sigh say, “Dudes… it all went way over your heads.”
(Photos courtesy of Time Magazine and View Askew Productions)
It appears the intent of your article was not just to report or comment but to accuse or discredit members or people who like the “Tea Party” movement of mayhem. Shame on you!! You are pointing out the speck of sawdust in one eye while ignoring the log in your own eye! YOU lost credibility when you took a side and showed your obvious liberal bent.
I for one do not believe in the faith of Islam, nor did I participate in public displays against the mosque, yet you lump everyone in the same boat with those who did and attempt to discredit those who like the Tea Party idealogy. Why don’t you jsut say Christians burnt teh equipment on teh site? Many “Tea Party” members are also Christian. Several murders were also radical Democrats but that doe nto man all Democrats are evil, does it? I hope not.
What is sad is that the local Muslims DID open a door to talk religion however nobody walked in. Reminds me of the Macedonian call- but nobody responded in this case. If Grace Baptist opened the door to dialog then I applaud them. But your accusing finger is not one bit more conduisive to a constructive dialog than those you accuse.
Dear friends,
Just for the records and to help maintain the honesty of your great site.
I am an official at the Islamic center of Murfreesboro. Grace baptist church DID NOT help our center in any way or form.
They have actually declined to response to ALL forms of communication we initiated with them.
Thank you
@A Kattih – Ah, well, thank you for informing me. I’ll have to be sure to check my sources in greater detail in the future. I had constructed that example Event from various articles discussed in one of my classes this past semester as well as various articles and blogs online, i.e. Time Magazine. It makes me a little sad, however, that it never worked out. Thank you, again.
@Mr. Floyd – I apologize if you had interpreted my message that way, sir. I do not mean to flame the entire Party. That would not be fair. Many of my local Tea Party members congregate from time to time at my place of employment and they seem generally pleasant people just as well as anyone else. I was merely citing statements from a couple of nationally published articles pertaining to the subject.
@All – Insofar, the purpose of the article (errors aside) was to make known the fact that nobody is right and the thing we are called to do is love one another despite creed, religion, nationality, ethnicity, AND political affiliation.
Unfortunately, throughout the span of history, religions have focused on the “truths” they hold which are little more than boundary lines between who is “in” and who is “out,” and look down upon those that don’t fit in the “righteous” mold. This has been incredibly prominent of the Christian faith (and I say that as a Christian myself, and a student of Christian history…).
Interestingly enough, the Cordoba Initiative takes it’s name from a community in Spain that thrived on the inclusion and community interaction of Islam, Judaism, and Christianity in it’s so-called “Golden Age”. Although, not necessarily fully egalitarian, nonetheless this community was groundbreaking in it’s tolerance for that period…
Unfortunately, Rob, educated individuals like Newt Gringrich think that the Muslim involvement in Cordoba was just a pre-cursor to the Mosque currently there and many of those opposed to the Park51 site seem to be of the opinion that the existence of a Mosque symbolizes “conquested” territory.
Sadly, the point is missed. There have always been angry responses to the majority of interfaith projects, dialogues, movements, etc. unless the initiative is below the radar. Whenever I’ve spoken to people of various faiths about the core motivation of their faiths, it’s always been a matter of love.
What I have a problem understanding is why this love doesn’t seem to apply to people of different creeds who believe in love themselves.
I love the beauty in diversity and I believe that it’s only through challenges that we grow in our relationship with God, others, and ourselves. I think the differences in faith can even be constructive in that sense.
Lest we forget love.
You have pointed out some serious issues that I think should be listened to more! Thank you!
I think the heart of what you are saying is the notion that “Truth IS Love.” I don’t think the western world has put too much of an emphasis on Truth (truth is a beautiful thing), I think we instead manipulated the word “truth” to mean objective facts. I wonder how much objective facts about our surroundings and the nature of God actually have on our everyday lives anyway. No doubt they do to an extent, but the things that run our lives are not historical, political, scientific, or doctrinal facts; they are relationships and feelings and ideas and imaginations. Jesus understood this more than anyone I’ve seen. He did not teach his disciples to belief true facts, he taught them to love one another. For Jesus truth could not be reduced to empirical evidence or graphed data; instead he said, “I am the truth.” I am still trying to grasp what exactly that means, but I think that it is beautiful. Let us stop trying to rob the word “Truth” of its meaning by equating it with facts and objectivity. I think Truth is best grasped when it is attempted to be lived.
@Derek – I think you’re right about the “truth” meaning “objective facts” and I think Rob hit on the head, though gently, with “throughout the span of history, religions have focused on the “truths” they hold which are little more than boundary lines between who is “in” and who is “out,” and look down upon those that don’t fit in the “righteous” mold.” as the negative consequence when we take things too far off the mark.
Love is Truth. Truth should be lived. I agree.